"Death From Above"
Needs to happen in NY and every other commie state
I agree with your post. And the poo poos are based upon what? How lay people think Article III judges decide legal questions . . . which would be lots like asking me what to do with the flaps as I brought my Super Hornet in for a carrier landing in a particularly rough sea. Briefly put, I would not have a clue. Not trained. No experience. No idea. I don't think like a jet pilot. It's fun to believe that lawyers think just like diesel mechanics but have some kind of bull sheet degree and got past the bar exam . . . but the truth is it's analytical thinking and it's based on precedent. The "common law," as our old buddy Oliver Wendell Holmes famously observed.Jonathan Turley: Second amendment realities – court rulings keep politicians gun control promises in check (msn.com)
Some of ya'll need to read this. Turley is no right winger by any means but is a very level headed law professor.
Amazes me how many of you just poo poo the ruling and are ready to give up before its had a chance for review by other courts including SCOTUS. JHC guys, take a win when you get it and let it play out instead of being so damn negative about a good ruling, a win for our side.
No one here knows how any court will rule going forward, certainly not SCOTUS.
You should read the entire thing, the version summarized by the news do not do the decision justice.This will be appealed.
the excerpts of the opinion that I have read seem weak to me.
We will just have to see where this goes and wait for a SCOTUS final ruling. It may not go that fart.
I don't know.The 9th Circuit will override the decision. State level bans aren't going anywhere unless SCOTUS says so.
I also need to add...I don't know.
This judge seems to be fairly good in writing his decisions and leaves little wiggle room for the 9th to overturn.
The 9th is going to have to find a legal reason to overturn him.