There are fake colt mags out there. If you read up on them you can spot them.The cheapest consistently reliable magazine in my experience is the Checkmate 7 round "hybrid" mag. They're around $20 and are basically an updated Colt 7 round design with feed lips that work well with a wide variety of bullet shapes. They don't look cool or tactical or whatever, but they work well.
I have had issues in 2 of my 1911s with the Shooting Star mags as well, they now sit in the safe unused.I must have gotten the lemons from Chip McCormick. I bought three of his Shooting Star mags several years ago, and they turned my will-feed-anything 1911 into a jam-o-matic. I replaced the Shooting Star followers with Wilson followers, and they run perfectly. Now all I buy are Wilson mags.